Transcripts For HLN Nancy Grace 20091007 : vimarsana.com
HLN Nancy Grace October 7, 2009
my friend, louie gohmert, has been here with me almost the full hour. we re about five hours five minutes from conclusion. i ll yield a couple of minutes to my friend, louie gohmert. mr. gohmert: with regard to the czars we ve seen over and over example it s of people who have been placed in these examples of people who have been placed in these positions and it doesn t do me any good or anybody in america any good to say, well, you know, prior presidents have used czars. not to this extent. not ever. and i never really cared for them no matter who the president was. i didn t like the bailout last year, i thought until this administration it was possibly the worst domestic action that s been taken in the last 50 or 60 years. that is until this administration just left $700 billion in the sand as it blew threw through more and more money. but then to have this massive spending spree, that s why we ve got people appointed by the white house, not properly vetted, the more we find out about these people, the more we re concerned they should never have been in those positions in the first place. and as we know, we ve already had one recently step down, should never have been there in the first place. whereas if you went through regular order there and had advice and consent of the senate, it doesn t mean they re going to be perfect, nobody is, no process is, but there was real ingenuity in the process that was set up by the founders. and the advice and consent is an important issue but the whole reason we set our founders set up a president outside the mainstream of congress, unlike the parliament that elect the prime minister from this body, it was going to be from outside this body so that there would be more checks and balances and the czars have done nothing but create scars upon scars with all deference to dr. suess. scars across america as they have been unaccountable to the congress, to the courts, to america and that really has to be changed. we need the sight in, we need transparency sunlight, we need the transparency. we don t need czars. mr. carter: reclaiming my time, agree with my friend and fellow judge from texas. we don t need czars that don t answer to the people. we intentionally designed the executive department to stand with checks and balances over it just like the legislative department is designed that way. we intended it and this is not the way our founding fathers intended this country to be run. we ve been talking tonight about the rule of law. it s about the rule of law, it s about following the rules. you know, if we don t hold each other to the standards that are required by this body, if we don t hold our colleagues to the standards required by this body, then why would we expect the american people to trust us? and i ll tell you, all of us need to be worried about the issue of trust. so i will continue to raise these issues and i will be glad to be joined by anyone in this house to discuss following the rules and obeying the law. with that i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back. without objection, and pursuant to clause 11 of rule 1, the chair removes the gentleman from texas, mr. rathes, reyes, as a conferee from the permanent select committee on intelligence on h.r. 2647 and appoints the gentleman from florida, mr. hastings, to fill the vacancy. the clerk will notify the senate of the changing conferees. the chair lays before the house the following enrolled bill. the clerk: h.r. 3663, an act to amend title 18 of the social security act to delay the date on which the accreditation requirement under the medicare program applies to suppliers of durable medical equipment at pharmacies. the speaker pro tempore: under the speaker s announced policy of january 6, 2009, the chair now recognizes the gentleman from pennsylvania, mr. murphy, for 60 minutes. mr. murphy: thank you, mr. speaker. mr. speaker, i ask unanimous consent that all members may have five legislative days to revise and extend their remarks and include extraneous material on the subject of my special order. the speaker pro tempore: without objection. mr. murphy: thank you, mr. speaker. mr. speaker, tonight, october 6, at 10:03 p.m. we have a very special night. my colleagues and i stand here tonight to champion the repeal of the don t ask-don t tell policy. repealing don t ask-don t tell is important. it s important for three reasons. number one, it is vital to our national security that we repeal don t ask, don t tell. we have kicked out over 13,000 troops since we enacted this law 16 years ago. we have kicked out over 400 troops just this year in 2009. when our commanders on the ground are desperate for troops in iraq and in afghanistan, now is not the time to throw them out, not for any type of sexual misconduct, but just because they re gay. number two, do we need to repeal don t ask, don t tell, because it is doing right by our taxpayers? it is costing american taxpayers $1.3 billion to throw these young american heroes out of our military. just because of their sexual orientation. it cost the american taxpayer $60,000 to recruit these young heroes to come in, to train them up, to make them warriors and then we just disregard them. just because of their sexual orientation. and lastly, the don t ask, don t tell policy goes against the very fabric of what makes our country the greatest country on earth. the fact that we re all created equal. mr. speaker, we have colleagues, members of this great house here tonight, to argue about the repeal of don t ask, don t tell. there s 176 co-sponsors to repeal this act. but one of these members is the highest ranking enlisted soldier ever to serve in the united states congress. he was a command sergeant major. that is the highest rank you can become in the united states army in the enlisted ranks. he s a sophomore congressman from minnesota, his name is ted walsh. he s an american patriot and a hero and i d like to turn it over to my colleague and my friend, tim walz from the great state of minnesota. mr. walz: thank you, mr. speaker. thank you to my colleague from pennsylvania. thank you for your service in the military, thank you for your leadership in this congress, and especially thank you for standing forward on to on this important issue. the colleagues who have joined us here tonight understand this issue is one of civil liberties, of basic human dignity and of national security. as my colleague said, i had the privilege and the honor to serve this nation for 24 years in uniform. i can tell you there is no greater privilege than putting on the uniform of the united states army and trying to do the best you can to make sure that our personal liberties and our security of this nation are maintained. the idea of denying that privilege and that honor to any american is simply unfathomable to me. it makes no sense. and i can tell you approaching this from a perspective, i m a school teacher by profession. i had students that i taught in the classroom, coached on the football field, trained in my guard unit and they went off to iraq to fight for this nation. they went off to afghanistan to fight for this nation. not once, not once in my career did the question of sexual orientation ever come up. not once was the ability of that unit to deliver the security and deliver their mission ever predicated on sexual orientation. not once did i see that this nation was safer because a soldier was removed because of sexual orientation. and this issue, and the position i was in as a senior enlisted soldier, my whole purpose in life was to make sure our troops were trained, make sure they were prepared to do the mission and make sure their well-being was taken care of. making sure they could pass their physical proficiency test. making sure they could fire their weapon to the best of their ability. making sure they understood the mission and they understood tactics to carry out the mission that was assigned to them to protect this nation. the professionalism of our troops is beyond question. the professionalism to be able to carry out a mission as assigned to them and to fall back upon their training has led us to have the most successful and profession military in the world proficient military in the world. the idea that these soldiers would be degraded degraded because someone doing the exact same thing beside them because of sexual orientation is not only a fallacy, it is degrading to the professionalism of the soldiers there. we serve today right alongside in afghanistan 12 nations that allow their military to serve as openly gay and lesbian soldiers. not one incident in that conflict has arisen because of that. and as my colleague from pennsylvania so clearly pointed out, as this generation of young people willingly raise their hands at a time of two wars to serve this nation, we re alternativing out turning out some of the most skilled warriors and turning them out of the military for a bias on sexual orientation that has no place, has no need and is not undermining our security. my colleagues are here tonight my colleagues who are here tonight are going to make and have already made a very eloquent case for this. the united states public has a very strong preference that we allow people to serve in the military, we allow them to do their duty, we make sure our arabling wifts are there and we ve sent many of them out the door because of this policy. it doesn t reflect the values of this nation. it doesn t reflect what we know in the military is a essential of trust amongst comrades is seans of trust among comrades and there is sense of trust among comrades and there is a quote, a speech given by the marine corps first rabbi and he was chosen and asked to give the eulogy over the dead at the battle of iwo jima. there was a strong bias about having a rabbi give last rights over christian soldiers. the decision was made to have three different services. but during the rabbi s remarks, he was very clear about this. enlisted man and offer laid dead together. black and white. rich and poor. sons of immigrants and fourt generation americans fourth generation americans. not one of those people asked the other why they were there. his point was, theirs was the purest democracy, arm in arm, brothers and sisters in arms, fighting for this nation, and for any of us to discriminate against another because of any perceived bias was to disregard and disrespect the valor and the memory of those who have served. so i want to thank my colleague from pennsylvania, captain murphy, an airborne soldier, served honorably in iraq, served this nation well, came to congress to do the same thing, and has courageously stood up time and time again for what s right, what s for the best security of this country and what keeps in the best traditions of civil liberties in this country. so i stand with my captain side by side on this. i can assure the american public the professionalism of our force and the unwavering commitment to this country of the military is absolutely in secure hands and to give other americans the ability to serve and be a part of that is something that this congress must do. so, captain murphy, i congratulate you, i thank you for doing this, i m proud to stand with you. you have over 170 of our colleagues with you on this. it s time to move this forward. it s time to erase this mistake for our security and for americans and i ll be with you every step of the way. so thank you for that and with that i yield back to the gentleman from pennsylvania. mr. murphy: i thank the gentleman from minnesota. there s two points that he mentioned mentioned that i d like to highlight. one is the fact that there are 27 other nations that allow their troops to serve openly. some of our truffest allies, toughest allies, great britain, israel, the aussies, they all allow their troops to serve openly with no detrimental affects. and secondly, the command sergeant major there mentioned ewoe jimafment i spoke to iwo jima. i spoke got an email from one of the colonels i met with. he said, and i quote, gay men and women have been serving honorably in our military for decades. he sent me a moving passage from a book about world war ii, reflecting on his experiences, a marine wrote, that lesson of tolerance was well lerved by the men in our company learned by the men in our company. during free campaigns in which we took part, valor and unselfishness were commonplace. i saw bravery and sacrifice all around me. one of the most courageous men i met was our navy corpsesman, a teenage boy who always put our well-being ahead of his own. in combat he cared for us, he bandaged our wounds and comforted our men as they died. often he would leave his position of relative safety and move out into the hail of enemy gunfire to treat a downed marine or pull a man to safety. on iwo jima, he risked his lifetime and time again to take care of his fellow men. on his last rescue attempt he was badly wounded when a japanese machine gun put a round through his thigh and another round in his chest. billy s wounds were life-threatening. and he was quickly transported out to a hospital ship for treatment. but billy didn t make it. billy was posthumously awarded to navy cross, our nation s second highest honor for extraordinary heroism under fire. i loved billy then and i will always love him. billy was a homosexual. every single marine in our company will be proud to stand with him and call him friend and brother. . i turn it over to my colleague, ms. lois capps. mrs. capps: thank you to my colleagues. i m so honored to be with you this evening and i thank you for organizing this time and for your leadership on this issue. it s a humbling experience to come to the podium and well following the eloquent testimony that you and our colleague, tim walz, have given us, the two of you having distinguished yourselves in uniform, serving our country on the battlefield and your ell o quens and your statements and your eloquence and your statements and testimony gives credibility to it and credence. and you have that ability to do that and i thank you that you are stepping up and leading this effort. i m honored to join you. i believe it takes those of you who served to express your leadership in this way, but i believe the rest of us who didn t have that experience of serving, but who are so grateful to those who did want to join you in this kind of effort. i m so honored to stand here this evening tonight with our colleagues from different parts of the country, from different backgrounds and experiences, all with this conviction that we have in lending our support to the military readiness enhancement act. it has been stated already and will be stated again, don t ask-don t tell is discriminatory, detrimental to the productivity of our armed forces and contradicts the very foundation of equality that the united states of america is founded upon. plain and simple. it is way past time for this prejudiced policy to end. over as you stated before, over 12,000 men and women have been discharged from the military since 1993 because of their sexual ownertation, because of their sexuality. that s over 12,000 gifted and qualified individuals our military could not afford to lose in the first place. we must keep the repeal of don t ask-don t tell on our priority list in this congress. and this issue must also remain on the national conscience as well. we have to seek out every opportunity that we can to jate our constituents that don t ask-don t tell threatens not only our national security but our inherent rights as americans. i m very grateful for the countless individuals who are working in our communities to do just that. many of them are current and former members of the military and do their service and do our country great honor by doing that s correct but i want us to widen that. we can t leave it up to those who served to tell this story out of personal experiences. we have to join them, because we are a part of that movement as well. and there are numerous organizations working across the country to inform people and citizens, all citizens, about the gin justice of this policy. i m proud that one of these organizations, the palm center is located at the university of california at santa barbara. nathaniel frank is a senior research fellow. i have listened to him and he has written extensively about how detrimental this policy is in a book entitled unfriendly fire. he explains how don t ask-don t tell has added to the challenge of recruiting and keeping qualified soldiers in the military and describes how the ban undermines cowhetion that it is designed to protect the very very reasons for establishing this policy had the effect of undermining troop morale and troop discipline and this is evidence that has been gathered now, substantial enough that it is way past time as i said for us to act on it. for organizations like the palm center and the testimony of our our civilian and military allies, we can and we must overturn the ban on gays in the military. i applaud the our president s stance on this issue and i look forward to getting the military readiness enhancement arkt to his desk as soon as possible. at least that s his goal and i m grateful to lay the groundwork for it. every day that passes with the don t ask-don t tell policy continuing in its place, the united states military loses out on more and more qualified applicants. for a country at war, this is simply inexcuseable and threatens the safety and security of our overstretched deployed troops today. every effort needs to be taken that those serving have the materials, the support and the work environment that they need to function most effectively. the brave men and women serving today in our armed forces deserve nothing less than the ability to be honest about who they are. thank you again, mr. murphy and my colleagues for organizing this hour and giving us the opportunity to speak out on this very important issue for holding this special order to bring further attention to the military readiness enhancement act. and i yield back to you again, mr. murphy. mr. murphy: i would like to highlight the fact that nathaniel frank does a great job. they do what s right by our soldiers and by our marines, airmen, sailors and coast gaurppedsmen. now it s my honor to turn it over to the gentleman from colorado, mr. polis who happens to be my sister and brother-in-law s congressman. i know brian and kathy are probably watching and i would like to turn it over to their congressman, mr. polis. mr. polis: they give me a lot of trouble. thank you for giving me the research that was done regarding this matter and i would like to thank representative patrick murphy for taking this challenge on and making our military stronger and saving taxpayer money. i would like to bring the attention of our viewers to a recent report that was published called the efficacy of don t ask-don t tell by colonel pr a/k/a sh. and this was a study done done that was done and won the 2009 national securities a competition. one of the quotes on the cover is from general omar bradley and says experiments in the army in the solution of social problems are fraught with efficiency and morale. this was not in reference to our current discussion but in reference to the racial integration of the united states military by harry truman in 1948. at some point, the so-called experimentation becomes the exclusion at this point in the evolution of our society. it is more experimental to use the military as a social incue baitor to deny gays and lesbians to serve. the military isn t the place for evaluating whether or not we as a society accept or don t accept homosexuality, but should be used as a fighting force to defend our nation. it is not in our interest as a country that lessens our military. if one considers the manpower and expense, don t ask-don t tell is a failure. he cites that it is $190.5 million for don t ask-don t tell. not only does it cost money but costs lives. when we put our personnel forward, we jeopardy ice the lives of men and women in our military. we owe it to the men and women serving to ensure the most capable person is in every job regardless of the race or the sexual ownertation of that individual. colonel pr a/k/a sh ends on this it is not time for the administration to examine how to implement the repeal of the ban. i know we have a number of other speakers here tonight. mr. murphy and that s testimony to your leadership and the importance of this issue and i look forward to engaging in a discussion after we have all had a chance to say a few words. mr. murphy: i would like to highlight this report. the colonel writes and i quote, there are potential lessons to learn from other countries that have lifted the bans of homosexuals. there is no mass exodus or coming out of homosexuals. prior to lifting their ban in canada, 62% said they would refuse to share showers with a gay soldiers. in united kingdom, 2/3 said they would not serve. in both cases, after lifting their bans, the result was no effect whatsoever. in a survey of over 100 experts from australia, canada, israel and united kingdom, it was found that all agreed the decision to lift the ban on homosexuals had no impact, i repeat, no impact on military performance, ready ns, cowhetion or ability to recruit or retain nor did it increase the h.i. vimplet rate. don t ask-don t tell has been costly both in personnel and treasure and an attempt to allow home sexals to serve quietly a law was created that forces a compromise conflicting with the american creed with equal for all and it is ultimately more damaging to the cowhetion and stated purpose is to preserve. furthermore after careful examination, there is no scientific evidence to support the claim that it will be negatively affected if homosexuals serve openly and the psychological predictions is that it will not impact combat effectiveness. it is now time for the administration to examine the issue and time to examine how to implement the repeal of the ban. and that, my friends, is from the joint force quarterly. that is a publication from the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff of our country. with that, i would like to turn it over to the congresswoman from california, ms. lynn woolsey. ms. woolsey: well, i would like to thank the gentleman from pennsylvania for organizing tonight s special order, because the men and women who serve in our military deserve nothing less than our respect, our support and our admiration. yet, the department of defense continues to deny them the respect they have earned by pursuing a devastating policy that is nothing less than discrimination against gay service members. don t ask-don t tell requires that the military discharge gay, lesbian and by sexual servicemen and women because of their sexual ownertation. a service member could be the best sharp shooter, best medic or language specialist in the military and doesn t matter if he or she is a captain or cadet having served three days or 30 years. if that member is openly gay, he or she is fired. don t ask-don t tell denies our nation their service, denies our nation makes us less safe because this terrible and open discrimination in the military does no good. it takes away great members that should be working in what they want to do in helping us be safer day in and day out. it s clear that don t ask-don t tell is a failed policy that not only punishes the thousands of highly qualified service members who have been discharged from the military, but it wastes millions of taxpayer dollars as well. when you add up the costs of the training, the food, the lodging, the equipment, the uniforms, the staff support and the transportation our country makes a huge investment in our service members to be the best in the world. but because of don t ask-don t tell, all of this training and funding is wasted if a trained service member is openly gay. how can we invest tens of millions of dollars in these men and women you know i want to sneeze, my nose started to run. i m suffering. thank you. that sneeze got me going. but all of this training and funding is wasted as a trained service member is openly gay. how can we invest these tens of millions of dollars in these young men and women, all of them who are desperately needed by the military, yet tell them they can t serve our country? this inflexible policy continues to weaken our nation s ability to protect and defend itself by retaining qualified sfts men and women. we must stop this. don t ask-don t tell has to go away. i was a freshman when we put this terrible policy in place. and believe me, i worked really hard trying to defeat it. but it s there. let s get rid of it. thank you, patrick for doing this. . mr. murphy: i thank the gentlelady from california and i look forward to partnering with her to right the wrong from 16 years ago from this congress and to finally overturn that discriminatory piece of legislation and to make it right for our troops. with that i d like to turn it over to a fellow hockey player from the great state of illinois, although he s a black hawks fan and not a fliers fan and by the way the fliers won tonight. i now turn it over to the great the gentleman from illinois, mike quigley. mr. quigley: thank you. i want to thank the gentleman from pennsylvania for his service as well. let me briefly try to put a human face on this. when you don t put a personal on it, you can manage person on it, you can imagine it s hard to understand the human cost with such a policy. i ll give you two. first of all, lee rinehart, four years after graduating from high school and after spending time at both public and private universities, lee decided he d simply not found his calling. so in september of 1995 lee surprised his friends and family by joining the navy. he served onboard the u.s.s. cao pence as an operation specialist, working his way up to becoming a second class petty officer in the combat information center tracking both surface and air contacts. while serving lee earned several metals and ribbons, including the navy and marine corps met medal. he was done in august of 1999. after time in the reserves and the events of september 11, 2001, lee wanted to return to active duty, this time to make it a career. this time he chose the coast guard. but soon after joining lee became a target and was vected. lee was given two choices. he could admit he was gay and be allowed to leave the military peacefully or he could stay and undergo an investigation with the same end result. discharge. the point of this story is obvious. lee had completed a full enlistment in one branch and earned an honorable discharge while serving in another branch, the uneven but while serving in another branch, the uneven and inequitable implementation of don t ask, don t tell ended his career. the implementation of don t ask, don t tell is uneven and subjects individuals such as lee to the whims and prejudices of individuals. second, lieutenant sandy soa. like the president of the united states, our dear friend, sandy is a fellow former southsider, this time from the bridgeport neighborhood. sunday, february 8, 2009, marked the one-year service anniversary of her active duty, full-time service to her country. shortly therefore she received an honorable discharge because of her orientation. she wrote a letter to the president of the united states, she writes, i am a second lieutenant currentlyly serving in the united states army. in addition to being an officer i am a christian, a woman and a chinese american. i am proud of all these identities. lastly, i am also a lesbian. on december 21, 2007, i was appointed as an army officer. in the oath of office i swore that i will support and defend the constitution of the united states against all enemies foreign and domestic. unfortunately i will not be able to fulfill this oath because the current policy regarding sexual orientation contradicts my values as a moral human being. today is the chinese new year. i hope it will bring good fortune to you and your newly elected office. today is also the day i inform my chain of command of who i am. one of the seven army values is integrity. it means choosing to do the right thing no matter what the consequences maybe. may be. as a christian this also means living an honest life. i cannot live up to these values unless my workplace, quote, provides an environment free of unlawful discrimination and offensive behavior. that is an excerpt from the u.s. army s equal opportunity branch. quote, we have the best military in the world and i would like to continue to be part of it. my mother can tell you it is my dream to serve our country. i have fought and overcome many barriers to arrive at the point i am today. this is the only battle i fear i may lose. even if it s too late for me, i do hope, mr. president, that will you help us win the war against prejudice so that future generations will continue to work together and fight for our freedoms regardless of race, color, gender, religion, national origin or sexual orientation. for 24-year-old sandy we are too late. for the many other gay and lesbian service members, our repeal main may be just in time. in my mind, having gone to iraq, i looked at the brave men and women willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for our country. many of them as young as my own children and i ll tell what you i didn t see, i didn t see those black or white, men or women, straight or gay, democrats or republicans. i saw americans. i saw warriors. don t ask, don t tell is a policy so fundamentally hypocritical that it encourages citizens to put their lives on the line, to serve a country built on freedom and democracy as long as they lie about who they are. lastly i m reminded always at times like this of what president lincoln said at gettysburg. it s been interrupted interpreted many ways but i like to think the essence of what president lincoln was getting to was, 87 years ago we created a country based on certain principles. most important of which is that all of us are created equal. what he was saying at getiesberg is, did we really mean it? gettysburg is, did we really mean it? did we really mean everyone? and i ask my colleagues to think about that, especially in a time of two wars, the storm clouds gathering over north korea and iran. did we really mean it? do we really mean it today? that all us are created equal. i think we all are warriors at least that much. thank you. mr. murphy: i thank the gentleman from illinois. those stories, those personal stories of our heroes that wrote to you are very powerful and very moving. i will tell you, since i took over the leadership of repealing don t ask, don t tell by enacting the military readiness enhancement act, i ve gotten letters from all over the country and from overseas in iraq and afghanistan. and one of those letters that touched my heart and frankly broke my heart was from a soldier in afghanistan. when i served in iraq six years ago i had 19 of my fellow paratroopers that gave the ultimate sacrifice. but one of them committed suicide. one of those 19 never made it home to see his family again. but this letter broke my heart because, and you ll see, this hero was dealing with the don t ask, don t tell policy. he wroits writes, sir, as you know, military spouses and other family members are important parts of the larger team. that is essential for a national defense. but such support is fundamentally closed off to the partners of gay service members. even though these partners maybe making exactly the same sack may be making the exactly the same sacrifices as their counterparts. gay service members and their partners have to worry that an overheard phone call, an intercepted email or other type of compromised private communication could lead to humiliating, career-destroying investigations. this is no way to treat american patriots. i write of these matters from personal experience. when a when the 9/11 terrorist attacks other occurred, i was in a serious long-term relationship. the active duty did i after 9/11 put a serious strain on this relationship and the relationship fell completely apart during my first deployment to afghanistan in 2003. one of the big factors contributing to soldier suicides is the breakup of serious relationships. this is exactly what i experienced and in the context of a combat zone deployment. i can still vividly remember sitting alone in afghanistan, cradling my government-issued pistol in my hands and fighting the urge to blow my own brains out. what made that personal struggle in afghanistan particularly difficult was the isolation that was imposed on me as a consequence of the don t ask, don t tell policy. a straight soldier in a similar state of crisis could go to his commander, his first sergeant, or his battle buddy for support. but if i as a gay soldier had gone to my commander with the details of my situation he would have been obligated to start the process of kicking me he out of the army kicking me out of the army. the don t ask, don t tell policy is wrong. i say this not just as an individual soldier, but also as someone with extensive experience as both a platoon leader and a company commander. what i ve when i ve been in such leadership spogs positions, hiveb straight soldiers share with me some of the most shockingly intimate details about their personal lives. i was glad that these straight soldiers put their trust in me because i was able to you are a each one the counsel or moral support that he or she needed at that time. gay soldiers should also have that right to go to a commander, to go to a first sergeant, to go to their battle buddy and not have toer worry about the ram financial have to worry about the ramifications of don t ask, don t tell. the policy shackles the hands of leaders like me. it prevents us from giving all of our troops the supportive leadership they deserve. the don t ask, don t tell policy throws up walls between battle buddies. it is an ugly stain on our national honor. end quote. i d now like to turn it over to the new freshman congresswoman from the great state of maine, ms. pingree. ms. pingree: thank you very much, congressman murphy. what a moving support did i story and moving letter. thank you so much for both gathering us here at this late hour and also for taking on leadership role in this extremely important issue. i m very proud to be here with you tonight and to be here with my other colleagues who are taking the time to just talk about how important this is and proud to be here with you. and add really a few words that can t come close to expressing what people have done in letters and stories that have already been told. but i do want to add a few words from my own perspective. in 1993 as we ve talked about today congress passed the don t ask, don t tell law that mandates the discharge of openly gay, lesbian or bisexual service members. under this law as we all know and have been talking about, at least one individual a day on average is fired because they are gay or lesbian. since 1994 that amounts to 13,000 service members who have been discharged under the authority of this discriminatory act. i am a freshman, as you mentioned, and i know this bill was passed in a different time, but as a freshman coming in here with different eyes, as a new member, nothing seems fair or reasonable about this policy. and as a member of the house armed services committee, it is clear to me that this policy does nothing to keep our country safe. and it does nothing to move our country forward in protecting the very rights that the brave men and women of the military are fighting to protect. in fact, i believe this policy is the has the opposite effect. don t ask, don t tell has been responsible for the dismissal of highly qualified soldiers, as we said, almost 13,000 soldiers that are our country dess desperately needs, at a time we re engaged in two active conflicts overseas. we ve talked about this report that s been recently released and a colonel recently said, as others have said in the joint force quarterly, don t ask, don t tell, has been costly. both in personnel and treasure and is ultimately more damaging to the unit cohesion, its stated purpose is to preserve. we talk a lot about the numbers, about our needs for trained members, like experienced arabic translators which we know this damages. but this is also, as we ve heard tonight, the thousands of stories of the men and women who willingly serve our country and, oh, by the way, happen to be gay. i heard a story recently of a soldier whose partner died while he was serving in iraq and because he was gay and because his partner was a male, he couldn t openly grieve or talk, just as you mentioned, to his commanding officer or to any of his partners. i heard about a young woman who wanted to follow in her father s footsteps but because she was openly gay will he is bean, she could not serve in the military and it was her life goal. i, like many of my colleagues have visited in iraq and afghanistan, and i have seen the chaos and confusion, the danger that our soldiers take on every day, in which many of them serve. in my state, like many other states, i attends the ceremonies where we send them off, where we welcome soldiers home, and i look at them, young and old, men and women, i, like many others acres tend the funerals when those soldiers don t come home and i ve hugged the parents of military members who don t return and know the grief that they feel. but of all those soldiers, whether you see he them in iraq and afghanistan, you see them as they re going off, you know, i just see young men and women, older men and women in the guard who are willing to serve our country, i don t see anyone who is gay or straight, i see, as one of my colleagues said, americans, people who are willing to serve. . they deserve our support and honor just as they are to serve our country. thank you for taking on this issue and thank you for being here tonight. mr. murphy: that was powerful. and i tell you, you were doing a fantastic job as a new member of this congress and we are lucky to have you in this hall. with that, i would like to turn it over to the the gentleman from new york, the former prosecutor from utica, italian catholic like my mother. my mother was from abruzzeesse. the great congressman from new york, mike arcuri. mr. arcuri: i thank you for your courage and determination for being here. this issue, i was sitting there and i turned the tv on this evening and i didn t know you would be here and i saw you here on the floor and i felt i wanted to come down and my comments pale in comparison to some of the comments that were made and stories that were told. but it s important that people weigh in. this is not the kind of issue that is reserved for people who are in the military, but this is an issue that affects all americans. we are so proud of the freedom that our country represents and there are so many thousands of people that have given their lives over the years to protect that freedom. and they did it to ensure freedom for future generations and to ensure that prejudice and discrimination did not continue as a blemish upon our country. and don t ask-don t tell is a blemish on our country and needs to be repealed and removed in the same way that any prejudice and any discrimination should be removed from the books of laws of our great country. i m here to say thank you for your leadership in this very, very important issue for stepping forward and the courageous way that you have and leading the charge to do not just the right thing, but the important thing, the critical thing for our country. i stand with you and i m proud to be a co-sponsor of your bill. and i m proud to be with you tonight. i yield back. mr. murphy: mr. arcuri said we should weigh in and not just leave it to those who serve in uniform. in the congress, 40 years ago, over 75% had military experience. now it s 23% of us have military experience. i will tell you that you don t need to be a set ran, someone who wore the cloth of our country to weigh in. and it s important to stand up and do the right thing. with that, we turn it over to one of the true champions of equality in this congress, the congresswoman from wisconsin has been in my home district in bucks county, pennsylvania. we keep asking her to come back because she has more fans than i do. and she is not running against me in the primary. but ms. tammy baldwin is a true champion for all of us for what is right in america. win win i thank you for your ms. baldwin: i thank you for your service to our country and yielding me some time this evening to talk about it. i join you in strong support of h.r. 1283, the military readiness enhancement act. we have heard throughout the evening that in 1993, congress passed don t ask-don t tell, a law mandating the discharge of openly gay, lesbian or bisexual service members. this law was a compromise to allow gay and lesbian service members to serve in the military so long as they didn t disclose their sexual ownertation, as long as they hid it. in other words, this compromise required our service members to conceal at best or to lie, at worst. and in an organization such as our military where trust and unite cohesion is so important, this was untenable. 15 years later, we know that don t ask-don t tell is misguided and it s a discriminatory policy. not only is don t ask-don t tell damage the lives and livelihood of our military professionals, but it deprives our armed forces of their honorable forces and needed skills. the armed services have discharged over 800 mission-critical troops and 15 american and nine farsi linguis ts under don t ask-don t tell. the financial costs of implementing this from fiscal years 1994 through 2003 was more than 363 million. now we can t afford to lose any more dedicated and talented service members to don t ask-don t tell. and surely, we can put these dollars, these resources to much better use. earlier this summer, i had the pleasure of meeting lieutenant colonel who was an exceptional servicemen who was being discharged under the don t ask-don t tell law. he has honorably served his country for 18 years as an f-15 e pilot. received nine air medals including a medal for heroism including the 2003 air invasion of iraq and was hand picked to protect airspace over washington, d.c. after the pentagon was attacked in september of 2001. the lieutenant colonel, who has flown combat missions in iraq and afghanistan against the taliban and al qaeda, continues to serve while the recommendations for his honorable discharge moves forward to a review board and eventually to the secretary of the air force. just two years away from his 20-year retirement, this dedicated service man stands to lose $46,000 a year in retirement and medical benefits for the rest of his life if he s discharged. there are approximately one million lesbian and gay veterans in the united states today, as well as 65,000 gay and lesbian service members currently serving. like the lieutenant colonel, these brave service members are fighting and dying for their country in two wars. they are making sacrifices and some are making the ultimate sacrifice just like their straight counterparts. it makes no sense and i just believe it is flat out wrong to discharge capable service members for something as irrelevant as their sexual ownertation. as my colleagues have discussed this evening, the military readiness act would proper hibt discrimination on the basis of sexual ownertation against any member of the armed services. the act would authorize the reack session of or wise qualified individuals previously accepted under don t ask-don t tell. the act would require that regulations governing are written and enforced without regard to sexual ownertation. it s long past time for congress to act to end discrimination against gays and lesbianses in our armed forces bypassing the military readiness enhancement act. i join my colleagues in repealing this dishonorable law as soon as possible and restoring justice and equality in our armed forces. before i conclude, i do want to commend you, my colleague from pennsylvania, congressman patrick murphy, for your bold leadership and your work in helping us move closer to repealing don t ask-don t tell. you have taken the lead in advancing this bill and i look forward to working with you to seeing that day come. mr. murphy: i thank the gentlelady from wisconsin. the fact that we spent millions of dollars in training to keep our families safe here at home, just to throw him out and discharge him like that is really a stain, a stain on our military and this congress for not acting quick enough. it reminds me, i had the great honor to teach at west point. i taught constitutional law from 2000 to 2003. and forbes magazine being the number one college in america, it costs the american taxpayer a quarter million dollars to train each one of those cadets to become second lieutenants, not just for the five-year duty commitment but for a lifetime of service. one of those commitments was lieutenant dan choi who is an arabic speaker, iraq war veteran and one of the 13,000 that we just threw out of the military, not for sexual misconduct. if there is sexual misconduct, throw them out. but just because he was gay. just because of a sexual ownertation. and that is wrong. and i now would like to turn it over to my colleague, mr. polis, for any comments he may have. mr. polis: i m struck by the number of stories and similarities that many servicemen and women over the last decade since this will policy has been implemented are kicked out for no good reason. what examine and i come from the business sector could do this kind of thing. it doesn t increase your competitiveness. if you have people that you put hundreds of thousands of dollars in training and don t like who they date and say you are fired. you have people who have excellent performance ratings, top of the category and say, i m sorry, we might put someone who has a lower rating because we don t like who you date. it s no way to run your company, your country and the best military. and what we owe to our men and women who are in uniform who put their lives at risk every day is to make sure that we put our best foot forward militarily and do everything in our power to protect every life of every man and woman who serves. when we remove people who would perform better, who are needed for certain functions, who happen to cost more to retrain, we jeopardize the lives of other soldiers who are serving with them. this has an effect on recruitment and retention within the military. i heard a few weeks ago from somebody s who is currently serving and facing the decision of whether to re-enlist. he said, you know, when do you think don t ask-don t tell will end. if you think it is going to end up soon, i rile re-up for another five-year period. i didn t know what to tell him. i said representative murti is working on it. i think we will get it done. if he chooses to leave, that s our loss. the cost of replacing that individual and training an individual, at a time when we need more men and women to serve in uniform is a cost to taxpayers and a cost to our national security. you know, all of these stories resound that we are engaging in extremely short-sighted policy. how can it be argued that these men and women with great command, great evaluations that are kicked out for no particular reason other than who they date, how can we argue that makes our military stronger? it doesn t. we need to correct this policy to make sure we have the best military to defend our interests here and abroad. mr. murphy: i know our time is almost over. one way to run a company or military, i will tell you there are military leaders that have served our country that are served our country that are adamantly opposed of
Related Keywords
New York, United States, Canada, Japan, Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, Australia, Texas, Afghanistan, Iran, Florida, Minnesota, China, Illinois, California, Wisconsin, Washington, District Of Columbia, United Kingdom, Maine, Iraq, Israel, Colorado, North Korea, Utica, Iwo Jima, Japan General, Italy, West Point, Italian, Americans, America, Chinese, Aussies, Britain, Japanese, American, Sandy Soa, Harry Truman, Patrick Murphy, Louie Gohmert, Lynn Woolsey, Al Qaeda, Dan Choi, Nathaniel Frank, Lois Capps, Santa Barbara, Omar Bradley, Tim Walz, Tammy Baldwin, Ted Walsh,