Transcripts For CNNW The 20240702 : vimarsana.com

CNNW The July 2, 2024



here right now on cnn. hello, everyone. i'm christianne amanpour in london. welcome to the ammanpour hour. in the next 60 minutes, we will take you around the world, to ask the questions, tackle the big problems, and let history be our guide. here is where we're heading this week. >> nobody's hands are clean. >> is america reaping of the consequences of value in the middle east? the former. df soldier joins me, before israel's last invasion of gaza. >> this is a leadership that i don't really trust. guns alone are not going to defeat hamas. >> two super heroes, a high stakes meeting months in the making. >> it is time to ratchet down the temperature. >> my exclusive conversation with one of biden's top china whisperers, u.s. commerce secretary gina raimondo. also ahead -- >> mr. gorbachev, tear down this wall. >> 34 years ago this week, that wall finally did come down. from the archive, my interview with reagan's partner, the last soviet leader, mikhail gorbachev. and finally, why the world's top relationship expert says we're evolving into something else. >> i've never heard you say anything like that. i mean are we becoming a different species? welcome to the program, everyone. i'm christianne amanpour in london. this week, the war in the middle east brought us the loudest voices yet for the very least humanitarian pauses to get life-saving food, water, and medicine, and fuel into gaza. and to help pave the way for the release of more israeli hostages. the white house is also feeling the pressure now, from all sides. as a new a. p. poll shows americans are divided over whether israel's response to the horrific october 7th massacre has gone too far. the head of the international rescue group told me a long break is essential now. >> the humanitarian cease-fire is to be at least five days, it has to cover the whole of gaza, it has to be properly monitored, there has to be the flow of aid workers, but also the flow of aid itself, of water, of food, of nonfood items. >> also this week, mixed messages from israel about what comes next after the fighting. here's prime minister benjamin netanyahu. >> i think israel will, for an indefinite period, will have the overall security responsibility, because we've seen what happens when we don't have it, when we don't have the security responsibility, what we have the eruption of hamas terror on a scale that we couldn't imagine. >> a senior adviser told me, a takeover is not on the table. >> we are interested in establishing new frameworks where the gazans can rule themselves, where there can be international support for the reconstruction of gaza and hopefully bring in countries, arab countries as well, for a reconstruction of a demilitarized post-hamas gaza. >> and just to be clear, the united states again says israel must not reoccupy gaza. former u.s. ambassador to israel went even further. >> if you take the long view of israeli/palestinian interaction, peace negotiations and conflict, the reality is that none of us is exempt from criticism, and all of us bear responsibility. the israelis for maintaining a 56-year occupation. building settlements. onerous on pation practices. palestinians for continuing violence and terrorism. and not responding when peace process offers were put on the table by israel. and the united states as what might be called the essential third party, of not doing its homework, and not being tough enough to see this process of peace making through to its conclusion. now, the idf this week surrounded and entered gaza city saying they have now destroyed hundreds of tunnels, taking the fight to hamas. so we decided to ask a former idf soldier about urban warfare. he was deployed to gaza in the last ground war in 2014. an he wrote in "the new york times" why he's convinced that it is quote a catastrophic mistake to believe that military force against hamas will make israel safe. saunders is israeli-american, and he is a jerusalem program director of extend, which is a jewish advocacy group for human rights for everyone in the holy land. b benzie sanders, welcome to the program can. i ask you first, as a former idf soldier, what did go through your mind on october 7th. what did you think of what happened obviously as an israeli, and what did you think was going to come next? >> you know, actually, on october 7th, i was not too far from the gaza border, and my wife's family's house, and it was terrifying, per the reports, and immediately, when i started seeing the images of the massacres, my heart went out, and when i saw the images of the retaliation and the bombing, i felt a deep pain, because i felt like i was seeing what i had experienced in 2014 happening all over again. you know, like then, on a smaller scale, we saw a horrific terrorist attack, with the israeli ground invasion then and before we went in, we were told that the areas had been cleaned out of terrorists, of civilians and the only people who remained were terrorists, and that ended up not being entirely true. and the entire neighborhood was bombarded before we went in. and you know, we lost soldiers from my unit, and you know, after i came out, i just hoped and prayed that we had decisively eliminated the threat. and that was the only thing that gave me a little bit of consolation for the death and destruction that i saw. and what i discovered in the years after that was not only did we not decisively eliminate the threat, but my own government actually was party to the bolstering of hamas and the strengthening of hamas, and i started becoming a peace activist and calling against these policies, which actually weren't as interested as much in defeats hamas as they were interested in expanding the settlement project and preventing a plin anystate. but when i think about the leadership of my country, my government, and the statements that they're making, basically, you know, saying that the entire civilian population is accountable, they should have rose up and overthrown hamas, or you know, the minister of finance who said he doesn't differentiate between hamas and the palestinian authority, i think that this is a leadership that i don't really trust. >> benzi you, after 2014, became a peacemaker, and you're also a reservist, what is it like for you at this moment, when so much of the israeli people, people around the world, in fact, believe that this war should happen, and that hamas should be wiped out, and that this kind of situation cannot continue. do you feel out of step with your own nation? >> well, you know, i think that fundamentally, i am aligned with the interests of my nation, and i do the work that i do, because i care about the future of my people. i think that what is still a question that needs to be answered, and that people are starting to answer the questions, ask this question to themselves, is, is the lie that we've been told, that the only way to defeat hamas is only through military force? i think the defeating of hamas is a very, very worthy and very, very moral cause. but i know that guns alone are not going to defeat hamas because hamas is not just a terrorist organization, it is an idea, and if we kill every single member of the brilgd, the idea of hamas will be strengthened unless we change direction and start working toward a political solution and i think the majority of people in my country maybe don't fully agree with me on that right now, but i speak to the diaspora jews, because i think their voice, and their involvement in what is going on in israel is crucial. to pressure their own government, and to pressure their own communities, to make sure that -- to pressure their own communities, to make sure that they're supporting a way forward that involves independence and rights, for both israelis and palestinians. because that's the only way we're bog to have peace and security. i think that's crucial and nothing will bring back the lives of the thousands of civilians who have been killed in the past few weeks. but in order to prevent this from happening again, and it will happen again, maybe it won't be as bad, maybe it will be worse, we need to work towards a political solution. >> benzi sanders, thank you so much indeed. before this middle east war, the united states had pivoted to asia. and up next on the show, why everyone wants to talk to gina raimondo, especially china, and my exclusive interview with h t timeme 100 bidenen cabinet s sey is next. welcome back to the program. and now to the delicate dance between two super powers, the impacts on us all, president biden is set to meet with his chinese counterpart xi jinping at the asia pacific economic forum in san francisco next week. until now, xi has been playing a little hard to get. but as california governor gavin newsom told me, from beijing last month, this relationship cannot fail. >> divorce is not an option. we have to define the terms of the future. and we have to live together, across our differences. >> now, in a moment, i will speak with one of president biden's top china whisperers, cabinet secretary gina raimondo, but first, let's look at this rollercoaster relationship which is nearly 75 years old now. >> since maodezong, one of the most complicated and consequential of our time, from the corner war, to panda and ping pong diplomacy, and president nixon's history-making 1972 visit, and then the restoration of ties between beijing and washington. as economic links tightened between the two, the tiananmen massacre of 1989 raised political and strategic tensions. >> we deplore the decision to use force. >> issues like trade imbalances and intellectual property theft. human rights abuses. >> sitting down -- >> the claims about genocide and forced labor in zinjiang are poor lies. >> territorial disputes in the south china sea. >> nearly 200 acres of new land. >> and the fear of the collision over taiwan have made the modern relationship between these two super powers complicated at the very least. and now it is president biden's challenge to manage. >> we seek competition, not conflict with china. >> and today, there is some hope for a re-set in relations. the very same diplomat henry kissinger, whose secret trip to beijing in the '70s paid the way for nixon's land mark visit, met with the chinese president xi jinping in july, and president biden has dispatched his most trusted deputies to smooth the way forward, including our guest, the u.s. commerce secretary gina raimondo. >> after all of her prep work, raimondo will be at the summit which starts today. she is a rising star in the biden administration. she is on "time" magazine's 100 most influential people list, and is "the wall street journal" said, everyone wants to talk to gina raimondo, even china. well, i have also been speaking to her. here is our conversation. >> secretary raimondo, welcome to the program. >> thank you. >> so i said, as everybody knows, that the world is in a total war footing right now, from the middle east, to russia/ukraine, so i want to know from you, ahead of this meeting between the two presidents, should we be prepared and buck ling in for war in taiwan? >> i don't think so. i don't think so. first of all, thank you for having me. as you say, we are in turmoil all around the world, and i will tell you, at least once a week, when i'm, you know, with the president, and watching him with world leaders, i feel so grateful that he is the man in charge of our country right now. he has the right temperament and experience and i was in china recently and i think they have the desire and we have the desire to stabilize the relationship. in my case when i met with my counterparts, we talked about using the economic relationship as a ballast for the rest of the relationship. we have to protect what we must and trade where we, can and i think that is really, that's the direction from president biden, as it relates to china, and i think that is where china is, you know, it's time to ratchet down the temperature, and let's do, i think the world, truthfully, looking to the u.s. and china, to be responsible, and managing this relationship. >> so this is a really big deal. and the previous governor of california, jerry brown, told me that there is no substitute for real conversations and getting a measure of each other for these two leaders. so what do you hope will come of the face to face sit-down over more than just 30 seconds? >> i would say, having worked with the president now for three years, he is at his best with these person-to-person meetings with world leaders. he has an amazing ability to relax with them, and just have an honest, authentic direct discussion, and that's what i will expect. i will be meeting with my counterpart, and that's what i will look to do. not to sugar coat anything, not to pretend that this isn't a great competition, but to be direct, and honest, and also to, as i said before, figure out what are the ways to most responsibly manage this relationship. >> so what do you think that you achieved when you were beijing, talking to your counterpart? >> well, first let me say, i was the first u.s. commerce secretary in more than five years to be in beijing, so candidly, the fact that i showed up and spent hours with the premiere, the vice premiere, my counterpart, was in and of itself extremely important. you know yourself, having covered the world for so many years, when there is no dialogue, that tends to devolve into conflict and increase tension. but once again, we are talking. and i'm able to put on to the table, the fact that u.s. businesses are feeling that china is increasingly uninvestable, because of the anti-espionage act, because of the lack of predictability in the environment, because of raids on u.s. businesses, and at least give them an opportunity to respond and make changes. >> i understand they really came at you hard to try to give on some of these major trade issues. and that is, for instance, the stringent controls on exports and most advanced semiconductors as well as the commitment to make them. what was your response to that? >> mi response to that is there is no negotiation when it comes to matters of national security. my response is to we need to, i need to protect the most sophisticated u.s. technology and i have to use every tool in my toolbox to make sure that our most sophisticated semiconductor chips, artificial intelligence models never get into the hands of chinese military. that being said, we also need to promote where we can. you know, the vast majority, we have a 700 billion dollars trading relationship with china, the vast majority, 99% of that, has nothing to do with export controls. >> and what about jobs? american people, people all over the world, are worried for their jobs. >> i would say that president biden is so focused and obsessed with bringing manufacturing back to the united states. it's why i took this job. when the president called me and said, hey, governor, will you join me to be the commerce secretary, and be my partner in revitalizing u.s. manufacturing, i leapt at that opportunity, and that's exactly what we're doing. by the time i'm done doing the work, implementing the chips act, will have hundreds of thousands of new high-paying semiconductor manufacturing jobs in the united states. by the time we're done implementing the inflation reduction act, we'll have thousands upon thousands of new manufacturing jobs in the united states. so we cannot give up on u.s. manufacturing, and that's why we're making these investments, to bring back a great deal of manufacturing jobs to the united states. >> madam secretary, stant by. when we come back, we will continue our conversation, we are going to talk about peace building over pasta. secretary raimondo, welcome back. what about ai? you were last week here in the united kingdom, along with vice president kamala harris, elon musk, all of those people, at a very important ai summit, and elon musk has said something really scary, that actually in the future, there may be no need for any jobs, except if people just happen to like to want to spend their time working. >> we cannot let that happen. that is a terrible outcome. it's within our control. obviously, this is a very powerful technology. we will make those decisions. and we will not let that happen. and that is the whole point of all the work that we're doing. president biden signed a comprehensive and bold executive order recently, related to artificial intelligence. ai is exciting. and when you think about using ai to find cures for cancer, or deal with the climate crisis, it is unbelievable. that being said, we can only harness the good of ai if we first keep a lid on the risks. >> i want to ask you about being a woman in the top job, i have spoken to so many strong and powerful women around the world, hillary clinton obviously comes to mind, and many, many of them, nikki haley is vying to the be the first-ever, you were the first female governor of rhode island, and you've had so many career milestones like that, how have you found it, you know, the race to the top, being a woman, and what is the effect of having women in top decision-making positions? >> it's hard. you know yourself. i ask ask you the same question. it's hard, there is no doubt about it. it's harder for women. people are used to seeing men in the top jobs, particularly in the executive positions, and at the time i became governor i wa one of four female governors in the country and sconstantly beig at governors conferences with being the only women but i will tell you this, i'm not sure the state of rhode island, without being a governor, would have universal all day kindergarten if we didn't have a mother who was a governor, the first mother to be governor of rhode island. in the chips act, that i am looking at now, i asked the companies, if they want to receive chips money, what are you going to do about child care, so women can work successfully in your facility? i'm not sure that would have happened if there were a man as commerce secretary. and i know that having women in tough jobs results in, you know, a different point of view and better decisions. i would argue, as you look around the world today, it is hard to escape the conclusion that we need more women in positions of leadership, leading countries, leading companies, leading major nonprofits, so i won't pretend it's easy, i won't pretend that it's, you know, women are judged by a different standard, but i will say we have to stay in it, because the world is a better place because of it. >> and i obviously would agree with you, 1,000 percent, and also, in the realm of peace negotiations, national security, and the like, but i did tease a bit about pasta, and you had pasta with democratic joe manchin and the chief of staff at the time, tell me about it. >> it may be that i'm italian more than the fact that i'm a woman, although by italian, my mother was the most incredible woman i've ever known, had a strong belief that there's no problem that can't be cured with a good italian meal and i do believe that as an italian mother myself. and i think it matters, to your point, about the meetings we'll have next week. and at the end of the day, we're all people, with the same, you know, humanity, and at the end of the day, solving these problems is to the benefit of our shared humanity, and there's truly no substitute for getting together in person, perhaps around a meal, perhaps in a casual setting, where you first talk about things that have nothing to do with the subject at hand, and then that will look at this person is a mother or father or has their own health struggles they're dealing with, that basic bit about trust building can go a long way and i will say that we've lost some of that, i would say arguably in washington today, it sounds trite, but breaking bread, getting t

Related Keywords

Tim Scott , Lot , Can T Win , Money , Donor , Move , Performance , Debate , Big Donor Money , Nikki Haley , President , Explanation , Ron Desantis , Chris Christie , Great Guy , Way , Anything , Value , Nomination , Hasn T , Doesn T , Panda , Bet , 20 , U S , Part , Christianne Amanpour , Laughter , Spending , Sunday , Everyone , In London , Cnn , Hello , World , Questions , Hands , Problems , Nobody , Guide , 60 , Hamas , Leadership , Guns , Soldier , Invasion , Demilitarized Post Hamas Gaza , Middle East , Israel , Super Heroes , Former , Consequences , Df , Two , Gina Raimondo , Biden , Temperature , Conversation , One , Making , Stakes , China Whisperers , Mikhail Gash Gorbachev , Wall , Ronald Reagan , Mr , Archive , Interview , Partner , Last , 34 , Something Else , Relationship Expert , Soviet Leader , War , Program , Species , Voices , Pauses , Food , Water , Pressure , Sides , Medicine , Help , Release , Hostages , Poll , White House , Americans , Response , Break , Rescue Group , Essential , Head , October 7th Massacre , October 7th , 7 , Cease Fire , Flow , Aid Workers , Aid , Items , Itself , Whole , Nonfood , Five , Responsibility , Security , Benjamin Netanyahu , Fighting , Messages , It , Scale , Table , Security Responsibility , Terror , Takeover , Eruption , Senior Adviser , Couldn T Imagine , Frameworks , Gazans , Reconstruction , Countries , Support , Arab , Reoccupy Gaza , Ambassador , Conflict , Peace Negotiations , Israelis , Reality , View , None , Palestinian Interaction , Criticism , All Of Us , Palestinians , Terrorism , Peace Process , Occupation , Violence , On The Table , Building Settlements , Pation Practices , 56 , Peace , Conclusion , Homework , Process , Third Party , Idf , Ground War , Fight , Hundreds , Tunnels , Urban Warfare , 2014 , Saunders , Military Force , Jerusalem , Program Director , Mistake , The New York Times , Israeli American , Israel Safe , Advocacy Group , Human Rights , Holy Land , B Benzie Sanders , Jewish , Wife , On October 7th , Mind , House , Family , Gaza Border , Images , Heart , Massacres , Retaliation , Bombing , Reports , Spain , People , Civilians , Terrorists , Ground , Areas , Terrorist Attack , Unit , Soldiers , Neighborhood , Threat , Thing , Bit , Death , Consolation , Destruction , Government ,

© 2025 Vimarsana